deviant art

Deviant Login Shop
 Join deviantART for FREE Take the Tour
[x]
more ▶

Featured in Groups:

Details

February 25, 2010
Link
Thumb

Statistics

Comments: 13
Favourites: 0
Views: 35 (0 today)
[x]
Honestly, I find this whole comment before you favorite spectacle to be a bit silly.

YES, it's nice to get comments.  I understand that.  However, 90% of the time your comments will be 'I like it" - or something along those lines..... which is exactly what a favorite says.  If I get comments I either want critiques or some in depth reason WHY you like it.  I don't mind the "this is nice/pretty/etc" comments but overall I'm not going to complain if people favorite something and don't comment.

When I comment on a piece, the chance is I'm not faving it because, usually, I'm critiquing it.  That's not to say that I don't leave my share of "WOW!  This is amazing!  I really love the *insert art term babble here*" because on really outstanding pieces, I feel the artist deserves to know exactly what it is about their work that makes it stand apart from others.  But when I critique it's usually on a piece that I feel could be pushed a little further or a younger artist that could use some general advice on how to improve.  Usually at that point I'm not really interested in the art itself but believe the person drawing it has potential and feel like they deserve more than a cursory glance over his or her work.

But there's a whole bunch of art that I just find inspiring so I just hit fave - but when people SEND ME A MESSAGE going "please comment before you fave." FIRST of all, I never do that - I always favorite before I comment (lol).  SECOND, I like your art.... but I'm not blown away by it.  If you look at my faves, I have HUNDREDS of images.  If I commented on every single piece, I wouldn't have time to live my life.  I'd spend all day on devART commenting on stuff.  



So... I'm sorry if this offends anyone but seriously, I don't think people not commenting is really that big of a deal.  Not everyone is going to give you valuable comments and a fave says the same thing as typing out "I like this, duuuurrrr."

And for the people asking for this simply so their gallery stats go up, FOR SHAME.  This shouldn't be about who has higher numbers.  You should be content with the fact that your art is appreciated and makes others happy.
Add a Comment:
 
:iconkomapsunida:
~Komapsunida Mar 9, 2010  Hobbyist Digital Artist
Ak I'm a feind for just faving. Often though I just like a piece of art for a number of reasons, they should be flattered that it merited a fav atall... I love comments, but I'm just as happy to see +fav in my messages, I won't throw a hissy fit if somebody doesn't comment^^;

I think its just a sign of vanity that people demand comments.. like in Myspace back in the day when people would be like "commentz plzzz!!!!!" xx
Reply
:iconsmoteymote:
~SmoteyMote Mar 9, 2010  Student Digital Artist
ahaha, yeah.
Reply
:iconnaida4:
*naida4 Feb 25, 2010  Hobbyist Digital Artist
i like when artists put that "comment before you fave" icon in their comments.
if a piece of art says that i generally will disregard the art and not comment at all, because really. a comment that says "i love this" is the same as a fave, as you said.
occasionally if there's an AMAZING art ill say something a fave it, but it's gotta be... breathtaking. :\
Reply
:iconpookat:
Getting nice in depth critique (or more often praise) about your work is nice and something to desire but "forcing" people to leave comments isn't going to get you it... it's either going to force them to awkwardly put together a long statement that may not be true or it's going to get you "that's cool" stuff.

I laugh at people who put that sort of thing in their description... it more often than not makes me not comment and since I can't comment I can't favorite it, eh? XD
Reply
:iconsmoteymote:
~SmoteyMote Feb 25, 2010  Student Digital Artist
ahah, I know.
Reply
:iconfishuu:
THIS <3 I've seen people who say stuff like "if you fave without commenting, I hope you die" and I'm just like WHAT? I feel bad when I do it, but seriously, a lot of times, everything I end up saying amounts to "wow, I love the colors, this is great!" or somesuch. Which sounds so ... simplistic and repetitive? @__@ Yargh.

Not that I don't love comments and all, but seriously. It's not that big of a deal to fave without commenting.
Reply
:iconsmoteymote:
~SmoteyMote Feb 25, 2010  Student Digital Artist
totes.
Reply
:iconlolip:
~Lolip Feb 25, 2010  Student Digital Artist
for a second there i though it was mandatory now. Scared me bro.
Reply
:iconsmoteymote:
~SmoteyMote Feb 25, 2010  Student Digital Artist
lulz. That would suck.
Reply
:iconlolip:
~Lolip Feb 25, 2010  Student Digital Artist
poop
Reply
Add a Comment: